When monks accused him of laying the egg that luther hatched, erasmus replied that he had expected quite another kind of bird a man of moderation, erasmus, hoping to see change from within, stayed with the church that had nurtured him luther loved the new version, as did other reformers in it, some found the inspiration to work on. Luther for his part, was not a humanist, he was a monk and a scholastic and as erasmus was in fact a humanist and never officially broke from the catholic church their relationship with each other is not really as close as some have suggested. Did erasmus lay the egg that martin luther hatched , this is such a complex question one would have to take into consideration that luther and erasmus did not think to keenly of each other, and disagreed on many factors.
Humanists did not accept teachings purely on the basis that these ideas have been around for a long time, they demanded evidence this is perhaps the basis of luther’s idea of sola scriptura luther and erasmus were very similar in the fact they both approached christian scripture as humanists this meant they were very skeptical of the text. Did erasmus lay the egg that martin luther hatched, this is such a complex question one would have to take into consideration that luther and erasmus did not think to keenly of each other, and disagreed on many factors.
Based on reading thus far, the answer would have to be no, erasmus did not lay the egg that luther hatched, not least because erasmus also clearly thought not. Erasmus and luther: the intellectual and the monk lia byl church history essay 1 january 10th, 2014 many have said that while erasmus laid the egg, luther hatched indeed, much of erasmus’s work was used as building blocks by luther. Erasmus did lay the egg that luther hatched maybe luther needed erasmus writings to write the paper of bondage of will but what began as luther admiring eramus' knowledge ended with luther claiming that erasmus was not a christian.
Erasmus’s response of luther rearing a very different chicken was a reflection after luther had published works, challenging the papacy, church doctrines, and the civil structure of germany, whilst erasmus remained within the catholic church, resolutely committed to reform from within. View notes - erasmus and luther from hs 032 at boston college erasmus and luther: laying the egg and hatching it leading up to reformation all we talked about question of authority (ancients) print. Erasmus and luther: a brief presentation perichoresis 62 (2008) 243 ans”8 while luther was still a little-known professor in a new university, erasmus was being read everywhere and was on close terms with innumerable people of importance also important was erasmus’ edition of lorenzo valla’s no-tes on the new testament.
Erasmus was an early defender of luther and agreed with many of his criticisms of traditional catholic piety there is some truth in the old saw, “erasmus laid the egg that luther hatched”—a jibe which originated in the sixteenth century among some of erasmus’s franciscan critics.